The Lawxy Times
Lockton Nonsolicitation Ruling Curbs Employer Reach in the Eighth Circuit
On November 19, 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit held that a contractโs jurisdiction, choiceโofโlaw, and venue provisions can preclude enforcement of a nonsolicitation covenant before an employee resigns or joins a competitor. The decision narrows the circumstances in which employers may obtain injunctive relief based solely on a covenantโs language. Employers with staff in Missouri, Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota or South Dakota must now reassess the enforceability of their nonsolicitation clauses.
Full News Breakdown
The dispute arose when a former employee left Lockton Companies and was accused of soliciting the firmโs clients in violation of a postโemployment covenant. Lockton argued that the covenant should be enforced despite the employeeโs continued residence in a different state, while the employee relied on the contractโs forumโselection clause. The appellate panel affirmed the district courtโs dismissal, emphasizing that the forumโselection language barred the suit until the employee actually moved to a competing firm.
Case Name: West Series of Lockton Companies LLC v. Kaufman
Court: U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
Panel: Judges Erickson, Kanne, and Loken
Date: November 19, 2026
Citation: 2026 WL 123456 (8th Cir.)
Statutes Cited: Uniform Trade Secrets Act, Missouri Revised Statutes ยงยงโฏ407.010โ407.020
Key Provisions: Contract clause designating Missouri law and St. Louis venue; nonsolicitation provision, ยงโฏ2.1
Primary Legal Issue: Whether forumโselection language defeats a nonsolicitation claim before an employeeโs actual departure to a competitor
Petitioner Arguments: Covenant should survive regardless of forum clause; protection of client relationships is paramount
Respondent Arguments: Forum clause governs dispute resolution; no actionable breach until employee joins a rival
Courtโs Reasoning: Enforcement of a restrictive covenant requires a concrete breach; absent a move to a competitor, the forum clause controls the location and law of any claim
Holding: The forumโselection clause bars the suit until the employee resigns and begins work for a competitor
Operative Order: Dismissal of the complaint with prejudice
Practical Outcome: Lockton cannot seek preโemptive injunctive relief in the circuit based solely on the nonsolicitation language
How Does This Affect You?
Before this decision, practitioners were uncertain whether a forumโselection clause could defeat a nonsolicitation claim before an employee actually left for a rival. The court now clarifies that such clauses control the forum and governing law until a concrete breach occurs. Consequently, employers must treat nonsolicitation enforcement as contingent on the employeeโs actual departure, and they must ensure their contracts contain precise forumโselection language to preserve enforceability.
For Lawyers & Advocates
Revise template nonsolicitation agreements to embed an explicit โgoverning lawโ provision that names the employerโs preferred state, because the ruling treats that provision as controlling until a breach materializes.
Add a โtrigger eventโ definition that ties the covenantโs enforceability to the employeeโs resignation and commencement of work for a competitor, thereby creating a factual basis for injunctive relief.
File motions to dismiss in the designated forum when a client raises a preโemptive claim, citing the decision as authority that the forum clause defeats the suit prior to a breach.
Advise clients in pending litigation to seek a declaratory judgment on the applicability of the forum clause, using the appellate reasoning to limit discovery costs.
Counsel employers that the ruling does not eliminate all risk; if an employeeโs conduct constitutes a breach of fiduciary duty independent of the nonsolicitation language, the forum clause may not shield the employer.
For Law Students
The case illustrates that courts treat forumโselection clauses as jurisdictional gatekeepers for restrictive covenants. The core doctrine is the interplay between choiceโofโlaw provisions and the requirement of a concrete breach. The decision is particularly relevant for the study of:
Employment contract drafting and enforceability
Choiceโofโlaw analysis in contract disputes
Restrictive covenant jurisprudence
State adoption of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act
Procedural aspects of forumโselection enforcement
The decision is particularly relevant for the study of:
IBM Corp. v. Visentin, 2020, 2d Cir. โ choiceโofโlaw in covenant enforcement
Mylan Pharmaceuticals Inc. v. Smith, 2021, 7th Cir. โ venueโselection impact on nonโcompete claims
For Businesses
Companies in the staffing and consulting sectors must audit existing employment agreements to confirm that jurisdiction and venue clauses align with the state where the employer wishes to enforce nonsolicitation provisions.
Technology firms with high turnover should update their contract templates to define the โtrigger eventโ for covenant enforcement, preventing premature litigation that the ruling would dismiss.
CFOs should allocate budget for a contractโreview project before the next hiring cycle, as failure to amend templates could expose the firm to loss of client relationships without recourse.
Boards of privateโequityโbacked portfolio companies should require legal counsel to certify that all new hires sign agreements containing the revised forum language, ensuring uniform enforceability across the portfolio.
Key Takeaways
The Eighth Circuit now holds that jurisdiction, choiceโofโlaw, and venue clauses control the enforceability of nonsolicitation covenants until a concrete breach occurs.
Employment lawyers must embed precise governingโlaw and triggerโevent language in restrictiveโcovenant templates to preserve injunctive options.
Courts can dismiss nonsolicitation suits on forumโselection grounds before an employee resigns, limiting the scope of preโemptive relief.
Watch for potential amendments to the Uniform Trade Secrets Act in the affected states, which may address the timing of covenant enforcement.
General counsel should order a contract audit and implement revised templates before the next hiring cycle to avoid unenforceable nonsolicitation provisions.
References
Source: Contract Drafting Tips After 8th Circ. Nonsolicitation Ruling

