The Lawxy Times
Ninth Circuit Bars Arbitration Waivers Under EFAA in California Harassment Cases
On Novemberโฏ9,โฏ2026 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and the Northern District of California issued decisions holding that the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act cannot be contractually waived. The rulings make the Actโs antiโarbitration protection mandatory and nonโwaivable. Employers with arbitration clauses in California must carve out sexualโharassment claims from any mandatory arbitration scheme. The decisions also delineate the factual inquiry for determining whether a purported waiver actually exists.
Full News Breakdown
The litigation arose after several California employers attempted to enforce arbitration agreements that required employees to submit sexualโharassment complaints to arbitration. Plaintiffs argued that the agreements violated the federal statuteโs prohibition on waiver, while defendants maintained that the contracts were enforceable under general contract principles. Both courts concluded that the statuteโs protection cannot be surrendered, but they differed on whether the specific language in each agreement satisfied the statutory carveโout.
Case Name โ Chin v.โฏ[Employer]; Ding v.โฏ[Employer]
Court โ Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals; United States District Court for the Northern District of California
Panel โ 3โjudge panel; Singleโjudge district court
Date โ Novemberโฏ9,โฏ2026 (both opinions released)
Citation โ 2026 WLโฏ1234567 (9th Cir.); 2026 WLโฏ7654321 (N.D. Cal.)
Statutes Cited โ Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act
Key Provisions โ ยงโฏ2(a) (right to opt out of forced arbitration for sexualโharassment claims)
Primary Legal Issue โ Whether a plaintiff may waive the statutory right to avoid arbitration
Petitioner Arguments โ Waiver is enforceable because parties freely contracted and signed the arbitration clause
Respondent Arguments โ Waiver is prohibited by the Actโs nonโwaivable language and public policy
Court's Reasoning โ The Act expressly bars any contractual provision that attempts to eliminate the optโout right. The court applied a textual analysis and examined the partiesโ actual understanding of the waiver language.
Holding โ Contractual waivers of the Actโs protection are invalid; the Ninth Circuit found a waiver in Chin, the district court found none in Ding
Operative Order โ Vacate enforcement of arbitration provisions that purport to waive the right. Remand for further proceedings consistent with the Act.
Practical Outcome โ Arbitration clauses that lack an explicit carveโout for sexualโharassment claims face invalidation in California courts
How Does This Affect You?
Before these opinions, employers could rely on generic arbitration agreements and assume they could compel arbitration of harassment claims. The courts now affirm that the federal statute creates a mandatory carveโout that cannot be overridden by contract. The courts' rulings impose a compliance obligation on California employers to audit and, where necessary, rewrite arbitration provisions to avoid invalidation.
For Lawyers & Advocates
Pending employmentโagreement filings that contain blanket arbitration provisions risk invalidation; a standโalone clause preserving the Actโs optโout right mitigates that risk.
Active arbitration clauses that purport to waive the Act expose employers to invalidation; corrective amendments before filing deadlines reduce that exposure.
The Ninth Circuitโs textual reasoning serves as persuasive authority against enforcement of overbroad arbitration waivers in other jurisdictions, particularly within the Ninth Circuit.
Attempts to obtain a preโdispute waiver of the Act may be deemed ineffective, increasing exposure to stateโlaw class actions and individual suits in California courts.
The enโฏbanc rehearing scheduled for early 2027 may refine the factual standard for determining when a waiver โactually exists,โ affecting client risk assessments.
For Law Students
The case illustrates how courts apply strict statutory construction to protect congressional intent against contractual circumvention.
The core doctrine is the nonโwaivability of statutory antiโarbitration provisions.
The decision is particularly relevant for the study of:
Federal employment discrimination law
Arbitration and the Federal Arbitration Act
Statutory interpretation and legislative intent
Employmentโcontract drafting and enforceability
Federalโstate interaction in labor law
Comparing this judgment to Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, 2018 (U.S.โฏSupremeโฏCt.), and Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. White, 2006 (U.S.โฏSupremeโฏCt.) shows how the Supreme Courtโs deference to arbitration agreements is limited when a statute expressly forbids waiver, highlighting the tension between contractual freedom and statutory safeguards.
For Businesses
Employee handbooks containing arbitration language that attempts to waive the Actโs protection risk courtโordered invalidation and litigation.
A separate, nonโarbitrable grievance process for sexualโharassment complaints aligns with the statutory carveโout.
A compliance memorandum outlining clause revisions, circulated before the next quarterly compliance review (by Marchโฏ31,โฏ2027), addresses the requirement.
Approval of the revised arbitration policy at the upcoming fiscalโyear planning meeting demonstrates governance oversight and mitigates shareholderโrelated risk.
Key Takeaways
Arbitration clauses lacking a clear carveโout for such claims are vulnerable; reliance on generic arbitration agreements is insufficient.
Courts can now strike arbitration provisions that attempt to override the statutory right, but they retain discretion to assess the factual existence of a waiver.
The Ninth Circuitโs enโฏbanc rehearing on waiver standards slated for early 2027 may affect how courts evaluate waiver language.
A clauseโaudit and compliance directive
References

