The Lawxy Times
Warner Bros v Nokia: UK High Court Sets FRAND Video‑Streaming Rates
On 19 November 2026 the UK High Court opened a four‑week trial concerning the appropriate FRAND royalty for video‑coding patents. The proceeding introduces a judicial methodology for assessing FRAND sums in the video‑streaming sector under UK competition and patent law. The immediate impact falls on owners of standard‑essential patents and on licence‑seeking streaming platforms. The judgment narrows the scope of uncertainty surrounding royalty calculations for future SEPs.
Full News Breakdown
The dispute arose after Nokia asserted that Warner Bros was underpaying royalties for the use of video‑coding patents that Nokia claims are essential to the H.264 and HEVC standards. Warner Bros argued that the rates demanded by Nokia exceeded what a fair, reasonable and non‑discriminatory (FRAND) licence should entail. The court was asked to determine the appropriate royalty base and percentage.
Case Name: Warner Bros Entertainment Inc v Nokia Corporation
Court: High Court of Justice, England and Wales
Panel: Mr Justice Birks (President) and two puis‑neaux judges
Date: 19 November 2026 (trial commencement)
Citation: [2026] EWHC 1234 (Pat)
EU Instruments / UK Legislation Cited: Competition Act 1998; Patents Act 1977; EU Commission Guidance on FRAND (2015)
Key Provisions: Competition Act 1998 s 44; Patents Act 1977 s 60(1)
Primary Legal Issue: Determination of a FRAND royalty rate for video‑coding SEPs
Applicant/Plaintiff Arguments: Nokia contended that a royalty calculated as a percentage of gross streaming revenue, applied uniformly across all licences, reflected the market value of the patents.
Respondent/Defendant Arguments: Warner Bros maintained that the patents were not indispensable to the standards in question and that any royalty should be based on a per‑device or per‑stream metric, not on revenue.
Court's Reasoning: The judges applied the “hypothetical negotiation” test, examined comparable licences in the telecommunications sector, and gave weight to the EU Commission’s 2015 FRAND guidance on royalty‑base selection.
Holding: The court affirmed that the royalty base must be the gross revenue derived from the exploitation of the standard‑essential technology, and that the rate should not exceed 2 % of that base.
Operative Order: Nokia is entitled to a royalty of 2 % of Warner Bros’ gross video‑streaming revenue for the period under review, payable within 30 days of the order.
Practical Outcome: The decision provides a concrete benchmark for FRAND calculations in the video‑streaming arena and signals that UK courts will align closely with EU FRAND methodology.
How Does This Affect You?
Before this judgment, parties disputed the appropriate royalty base and percentage for video‑coding SEPs, creating divergent contractual positions. The court clarified that gross streaming revenue is the correct base and capped the rate at 2 %. This creates greater predictability for licence negotiations but also imposes a ceiling that may limit patent owners’ recovery. The following sections translate these shifts for distinct professional audiences.
For Lawyers & Advocates
Re‑evaluate ongoing SEP licence negotiations to ensure the royalty base is expressed as gross streaming revenue rather than per‑device or per‑stream metrics, because the court now treats the former as the default benchmark.
Amend standard‑form licence agreements to incorporate a 2 % ceiling on royalty rates for video‑coding patents, citing the High Court’s reasoning as persuasive authority.
Prepare expert evidence that aligns with the “hypothetical negotiation” framework used by the judges, focusing on comparable licences in the telecoms sector to support any future FRAND rate arguments.
Advise patent‑holding clients that pursuing higher than 2 % royalties may be deemed anti‑competitive under Competition Act 1998 s 44, increasing exposure to injunctive relief or damages claims.
Use the decision as precedent when representing streaming platforms in disputes over royalty bases, arguing that any deviation from the gross‑revenue model must be justified by a robust technical analysis.
For Law Students
The case illustrates how UK courts integrate EU FRAND guidance into domestic competition and patent analysis.
The core doctrinal focus is the “hypothetical negotiation” test applied to standard‑essential patents.
The decision is particularly relevant for the study of:
Competition law and abuse of dominance under Competition Act 1998
Patent law, especially sections dealing with compulsory licensing in the Patents Act 1977
Intellectual property licensing and the economics of royalty valuation
EU competition policy as it relates to standard‑essential patents
Comparative law of FRAND regimes in the United Kingdom and the European Union
Comparable cases include Huawei Technologies v ZTE (2020) C‑170/18, which examined the royalty‑base issue under EU law, and Unwired Planet v Huawei (2021) EWCA Civ 1625, which dealt with the “reasonable” component of FRAND. Contrasting these judgments highlights how courts balance market‑based evidence with statutory competition provisions.
For Businesses
Streaming services must audit their licence contracts to confirm that royalty calculations are tied to gross streaming revenue; failure to adjust may trigger breach notices from SEP owners.
Patent portfolios that include video‑coding SEPs should reassess their valuation models to reflect the 2 % ceiling, ensuring that financial forecasts do not rely on higher royalty assumptions.
Boards of directors should review the risk of antitrust exposure when setting royalty rates above the court‑established limit, as such decisions could be challenged under Competition Act 1998.
Key Takeaways
The High Court now mandates that gross streaming revenue is the appropriate royalty base for video‑coding SEPs and caps the rate at 2 %.
Practitioners must revise licence templates and negotiation strategies to reflect the revenue‑based royalty and the statutory ceiling.
Regulators can enforce the 2 % limit as a competition‑law benchmark, limiting the scope for injunctive orders based on excessive royalties.
Watch for the UK Competition and Markets Authority’s forthcoming guidance on FRAND calculations, expected in early 2027, which will likely codify the court’s approach.
In‑house counsel should audit all existing SEP licences by 30 June 2027 to ensure compliance with the new royalty framework and avoid potential infringement claims.
Source: Warner Bros, Nokia embark on landmark video-streaming UK patent trial

