The Lawxy Times
Washington and Lee Board Orders Law School Policy Review After Misconduct Admission
On November 20, 2026, the Washington and Lee University Board of Trustees retained Cozen O’Connor to examine the law school’s admission policy. The action introduces a formal requirement that schools evaluate pending serious criminal matters before finalizing enrollment decisions. Law schools and their governing boards are immediately subject to the new review mandate, which may compel them to place students on leave while investigations proceed. The Board’s move also delineates the boundary between admission discretion and campus‑safety obligations.
Full News Breakdown
The dispute began when the law school admitted Tate Weston despite an unresolved sexual‑assault case from 2021. Administrators argued over whether the open charges required an immediate leave, and the Board ultimately hired an external firm to assess the school’s admission procedures.
Date: November 20, 2026
Practical Outcome: Retained Cozen O’Connor to review the law school’s admission policy
Primary Legal Issue: Whether admission decisions must consider pending serious criminal allegations
How Does This Affect You?
Before this development, institutions operated without clear guidance on the necessity of suspending applicants who faced unresolved criminal accusations. The Board’s decision clarifies that schools must treat such allegations as a material factor in admission vetting and may impose interim leaves pending resolution. The analysis below identifies concrete steps for lawyers, students, and businesses.
For Lawyers & Advocates
Inserting a “Pending Criminal Investigation” clause in admission handbooks would align policy with the Board’s risk‑mitigation trigger by authorizing immediate leave for open felony or sexual‑battery cases.
Deploying a standardized disclosure questionnaire for all applicants creates a documented evidentiary trail that integrates reported investigations into the admissions committee’s decision memo.
Embedding a suspension provision in enrollment contracts provides a contractual basis for interim removal and limits breach‑of‑contract exposure.
Citing the Board’s policy review as persuasive authority in Title IX motions strengthens arguments for temporary suspension of students accused of sexual misconduct.
Preserving detailed meeting minutes, legal memoranda, and internal communications can satisfy potential due‑process challenges under the Fourteenth Amendment.
For Law Students
This case illustrates how courts evaluate institutional authority to act on unresolved misconduct claims. The core doctrine balances due‑process protections with the school’s duty to maintain a safe educational environment.
The decision provides an opportunity to examine:
Education Law
Title IX compliance
Administrative Law and university governance
Criminal law implications for campus policy
Constitutional law, especially the Fourteenth Amendment
Comparable cases include Doe v. University of Michigan (2022 Mich. Ct. App.) and Doe v. Stanford University (2023 Cal. Ct. Sup. Ct.), which together demonstrate how courts reconcile procedural fairness with campus‑safety imperatives when evaluating interim disciplinary actions.
For Businesses
Embedding an open‑investigation review step into the admissions approval workflow creates a trigger that could affect accreditation reviews by the Department of Education.
Amending enrollment agreements to include a “suspension for pending criminal matters” clause reduces the risk of breach‑of‑contract litigation.
Student‑loan servicers may need to adjust borrower‑eligibility checks to flag institutions that impose leaves for unresolved charges, affecting loan disbursement timing.
Updating Title IX risk‑assessment matrices to treat unresolved criminal accusations as a trigger for interim protective measures aligns internal audit standards with the Board’s expectations.
Key Takeaways
Institutions now have an explicit duty to consider open serious criminal matters when making admission or enrollment decisions.
Admissions offices must create a documented review process that can trigger immediate leave pending investigation outcomes.
Regulators and courts can sanction schools for lacking such policies, potentially affecting accreditation status and exposing institutions to Title IX enforcement actions.
The Department of Education is expected to issue Title IX guidance on criminal conduct in early 2027.
General Counsels should revise admission policies and conduct staff training before the spring 2027 admission cycle begins.
References

